One of the things that bums me out the most about big media is that there’s so little room for corrections, and for dissenting voices. Maybe a paper will have a token op-ed columnist that doesn’t march in lock-step with its basic direction. Maybe it’ll run an occasional high-profile “we blew it” when a story is just completely and absolutely wrong. But, mostly, disagreements are kept far, far below the water line.
Blogs are different, of course. The best bloggers — guys like Andrew Sullivan, for example — aren’t afraid to lend their online podiums to people who don’t share their views. They’re willing to be called idiots and fakes on their home turf.
I admire that. So much so that I’m starting a new feature on Defense Tech. Every so often, I’m going to highlight a comment, blog entry, or rant that does a really good job at countering an argument of mine — at telling me I’m full of shit. Call it the “F.O.S. Files.“
The first installment comes from Will Brown of the Warrior Class Blog. It’s a response to my “Enemy is Me” post, in which I mocked the idea that assembling bits of unclassified information could somehow cause soldiers harm.
Discovering specifically what to learn about, and where that information is to be found, is a much greater challenge then Mr. Shachtman is apparently willing to consider. Google and other on-line search engines are invaluable intelligence gathering tools that are available to anyone with the technological capability to access them. Even so, they present the same stumbling block as do dictionaries familiar to any third grader; you have to know where to look, how to spell the word in the first place, in order to look it up at all. It is in this regard that Mr. Shachtmans protestations fall flat. By providing the enemy with informed inspiration to guide information searchs [sic], such concerns as he dismisses give vital starting guidance to enemy research into developing counter-measures.
Now, Brown goes on to make some less-smart accusations. He implies, for instance, that the reason I’m defending the right to round up unclassified information is so I can maintain “a viable economic strategy” for myself. (Trust me, there are easier ways to make a buck.) But, still, the man’s basic counter-argument is solid. Im looking forward to the next F.O.S. file.
{ 7 comments… read them below or add one }
Dunno that you need to formalize the idea that folk disagree from time to time. Appropriate linky loveliness is more than sufficient and more than the MSM sees fit to provide.
Great idea! It would be even more interesting if you occasionally invited folks who disagree to write full-length posts.
I like it, Haninah.
nms
lmao…ok, i was honestly thinking it was the Freedom Of Speech files…ahhhh, the brain wakes up slowwwwwwly these days….
I think you do a pretty good job of linking back to those that don’t agree with you. That covers most of it in my view. If someone writes stuff back to you about your post that you think is good, posting like you did works great as well. You have the MSM beat all to hell, good job Noah.
Will Brown is right
I’m honored to be the first, Mr. Shachtman … and obviously need to check our refers files more often.
Let me just say the commenter John Henry Key is obviously a deeply insightful individual.
I would also like to point out that my observation about the strategy of your occupation wasn’t intended as being personal only to you. The same strategic principle’s apply to anyone in your profession and should be considered by any reader when making an evaluation of the subject matter on offer. I should have made that point more clear in the original.
Do please drop by our blog and offer informed commentary.