Stephen I. Schwartz is the former executive director and publisher of the Bulletin of the Atomic Scientists, and the editor and co-author of Atomic Audit: The Costs and Consequences of U.S. Nuclear Weapons Since 1940. This his first post for Defense Tech. I’m looking forward to more.
The headline sure seemed scary: “Web site exposes Air Force One defenses.” And the copy down below was just as breathless, discussing a nameless online document which gave “specific information about the anti-missile defenses” on the two specially-converted 747-200B series planes serving as Air Force One (Air Force designation VC-25A). “Detailed interior maps” showed, among other things, the “location of Secret Service agents” and, more alarmingly, “the location where a terrorist armed with a high-caliber sniper rifle could detonate the tanks that supply oxygen to Air Force ones medical facility.” You could almost forgive the Drudge Report for posting the San Francisco Chronicle story instantly.
But the Chron failed to mention the most important and most glaringly obvious — aspect of the document: It’s part of a safety manual, written so firefighters and emergency responders can quickly rescue Air Force One’s pilots and passengers if there’s an accident or mishap. The document was cleared for international public release ages ago.
The article says that “the Air Force reacted with alarm last week after The Chronicle told the Secret Service” about the document, while the Secret Service had no comment. Writer Paul J. Caffera quotes a public affairs officer from the 89th Airlift Wing at Andrews Air Force Base saying “it is not a good thing” to have such information in the public domain. For good measure he throws in comments from a national security analyst Daniel Gour (whose quote actually gives away the “secret” of the anti-missile defense system deployed on the aircraft) and former congressman and White House chief of staff Leon Panetta, who says, “If I were still chief of staff, I would order the damned site (to) pull it down.“
Of course, protecting Air Force One should be given the absolute highest priority. Every measure should be taken to ensure the safety of everyone aboard. But would yanking this document really help? Or could it hurt?
The document Caffera found is part of the Air Forces Technical Order 00-105E-9 — Aerospace Emergency Rescue and Mishap Response Information (Emergency Services) Revision 11. It resided, until recently, on the web site of the Air Logistics Center at Warner Robins Air Force Base. The purpose is pretty straight-ahead: “Recent technological advances in aviation have caused concern for the modern firefighter.” So the document gives “aircraft hazards, cabin configurations, airframe materials, and any other information that would be helpful in fighting fires.“
As a February 2006 briefing from the Air Force Civil Engineer Support Agency explains, the document is “used by foreign governments or international organizations and is cleared to share this information with the general global publicdistribution is unlimited.” The Technical Order existed solely on paper from 1970 to mid-1996, when the Secretary of the Air Force directed that henceforth all technical orders be distributed electronically (for a savings of $270,000 a year). The first CD-ROMs were distributed in January 1999 and the web site at Warner Robins was set up 10 months later. A month after that, the web site became the only place to access the documents, which are routinely updated to reflect changes in aircraft or new regulations.
But back to the document Caffera found. It’s hardly a secret that Air Force One has defenses against surface-to-air missiles. The page that so troubled Caffera indicates that the plane employs infrared countermeasures, with radiating units positioned on the tail and next to or on all four engine pylons. Why does the document provide that level of detail? Because emergency responders could be injured if they walk within a certain radius of one of the IR units while it is operating.
Nor is it remarkable that Secret Service agents would sit in areas on the plane that are close to the Presidents suite, as well as between reporters, who are known to sit in the back of the plane, and everyone else. Exactly how this information endangers anyone is unclear. But it would help emergency responders in figuring out where to look for people in the event of an accident. (Interestingly, conjectural drawings of the layout of Air Force One like this one are pretty close to the real deal.)
As for hitting the medical oxygen tanks to destroy the plane, you’d have to be really, really lucky to do that while the plane is moving at any significant speed. And if it’s standing still and you are after the President and armed with a high-caliber sniper rifle, why wouldnt you target him directly? Besides, if you wanted to make the plane explode, it would be much easier to aim for the fuel tanks in the wings (which when fully-loaded hold 53,611 gallons). Terrorists dont need a diagram to figure that out. But a rescuer would want this information so that the oxygen valves could be turned off to mitigate the risk of a fire or explosion.
Interestingly, what Caffera either missed or ignored is that the Technical Order includes detailed information on most of the fixed-wing and rotary aircraft operated by the military, by NATO, and by civilian agencies like the Forest Service and the National Oceanic and Atmospheric Administration. Other U.S. military aircraft found in the document include the Global Hawk, SR-71, COBRA BALL and RIVET JOINT (both using modified versions of the C-135), the B-2 bomber, the F-117A fighter, the E-6B (inheritor of the Cold War-era “Looking Glass” and TACAMO missions), the National Airborne Operations Center (codename “Nightwatch”), to be used by the President or his successor in the event of a nuclear war, and even the Airborne Laser and the International Space Station.
Caffera’s story was quickly posted on the Drudge Report and subsequently picked up and picked apart in all sorts of places. A more tempered response from John Noonan at the Officers’ Club, who’s in the Air Force.
Predictably, many folks criticized the Chronicle for publishing the article and, in their view, jeopardizing security. There was even speculation that the drawings were decoys designed to mislead terrorists. Few, however, have actually looked closely at the document, even as they point out the relative ease with which they located it. And no one has explained its true purpose or the fact that it has been freely available online for over seven years.
Having read all this, youll probably want to peruse the documents yourself, as many thousands of people, including yours truly, have already done. Well you cant, because just as predictably theyve been yanked off the web (though you can find cached text-only versions via Google). And not only the current version is gone, but previous ones as well.
Did the folks at Warner Robins notice the fuss and undertake some damage control? No, a reporter from Londons The Guardian newspaper telephoned Robins about the story and found a spokesman who indicated he was unaware of “the problem.” But not for long. A few hours later, the documents were gone.
Caffera has another explanation in a follow-up article in todays Chronicle that breathlessly begins:
Air Force and Pentagon officials scrambled Monday to remove highly sensitive security details about the two Air Force One jetliners after The Chronicle reported that the information had been posted on a public Web site.
This time, Caffera correctly describes the purpose of the Technical Order. Nevertheless, according to Air Force spokeswoman Lt. Col. Catherine Reardon, “We are dealing with literally hundreds of thousands of Web pages, and Web pages are reviewed on a regular basis, but every once in a while something falls through the cracks. We can’t even justify how (the technical order) got out there. It should have been password-protected. We regret it happened. We removed it, and we will look more closely in the future.“
An Air Force source familiar with the history and purpose of the documents who asked not to be identified laughed when told of the above quote, reiterated that the Technical Order is and always has been unclassified, and said it is unclear how the document can be distributed now, adding that firefighters in particular wont like any changes that make their jobs more difficult or dangerous.
“The order came down this afternoon [Monday] to remove this particular technical order from the public Web site, said John Birdsong, chief of media relations at Warner Robins Air Logistics Center, the air base in Georgia that had originally posted the order on its publicly accessible Web site. According to Birdsong, the directive to remove the document came from a number of officials, including Dan McGarvey, the chief of information security for the Air Force at the Pentagon.“
Muddying things still further are comments from Jean Schaefer, deputy chief of public affairs for the Secretary of the Air Force. “We have very clear policies of what should be on the Web,” she said. “We need to emphasize the policy to the field. It appears that this document shouldn’t have been on the Web, and we have pulled the document in question. Our policy is clear in that documents that could make our operations vulnerable or threaten the safety of our people should not be available on the Web.“
And now, apparently, neither should documents that help ensure the safety of our pilots, aircrews, firefighters and emergency responders.
– Stephen I. Schwartz
UPDATE 3:17 PM: Cryptome has the document here.
(Big ups: Russ)
{ 203 comments… read them below or add one }
DS: because military aircraft can and do go down in populated areas. “Letting it burn” isn’t necessarily an option. Some years ago there was a warehouse fire in Los Angeles. Firefighters responded as if it were any other fire, not realizing that the warehouse stored exotic industrial metals. Not only could they not put the fire out but pouring water on it made it worse until they got more information about what they were up against.
Sorry for the President’s security, but other people’s security matters, too. When these planes go down the firefighters aren’t going to have time to try to make contact with the Air Force and wend their way through the tortured chain of command to find someone who can make a decision and give them the information they need. Their command center has to be able to hit a link and tell them where the oxygen tanks are and where to look for survivors.
But this is another example of the personality cult we’ve built around the office of the President. Perhaps if the firefighter arrange for a parade and 21-gun salute they will then be allowed to put out the damned fire.
“We have very clear policies of what should be on the Web,”
Just searched some 3 minutes and found this:
—-
ORDER 00-105E-9, 1 MAY 2005, REVISION 10.
THIS IS SEGMENT 3 COVERING CHAPTER 5.
Page 30
B-2
T.O. 00-105E-9
B-2.
ENGINE, WEAPONS BAY AND
EQUIPMENT BAY FIRE ACCESS
1. ENGINE FIRES
a. Use the Fire Panels as illustrated.
2. WEAPONS BAY FIRES
When opening the weapons bay doors, to
prevent injury or death to personnel, insure
that area under weapons bay doors is clear
of personnel and equipment before opening.
a.
To open the weapons bay doors, locate the
Ground Control Panel under a latched cover,
right side of crew entry door opening. Set
function switch to GRD. Press ENABLE
switch and hold Left or Right bay doors
switch in open position until doors are open,
then release ENABLE switch.
3.
AFT EQUIPMENT BAY FIRES
Failure to DISABLE AEB door upon entering
AEB could result in injury or death. Insure no
personnel remain inside and are clear and aft
of area prior to closing AEB door. Failure to
comply could result in injury or death.
NOTE:
To open AEB door, weapons bay doors must be
open to access disable switch.
AEB door seals are sharp. AEB ladder must be
pinned prior to ascent. Do not stand on door.
NOTE:
Weapons bay doors and AEB door can be
opened either electrically or manually
—-
Aheemmm …..
Want the new ‘big money toy’?
—
F/A-22A.
F-22A
T.O. 00-105E-9
8
AIRCRAFT HAZARDS-Continued
1. WEAPONS STORAGE AND LOCATIONS
NOTE:
Weapons information is discussed on this page and the next.
a. Ammunition storage for the M61A2 20mm multibarrel cannon
Linear Linkless system located immediately forward of the right
main landing gear door and across the belly of aircraft. Storage
system is an overlapping conveyor belt design holding 480 rounds.
b. Air-to Air: AIM-9M/X Sidewinder (1 per side weapons bay on LAU).
c. Air-to-Air: AIM-120C AMRAAM, 3 per bay – total of 6.
d. Air-to Ground: 2 GBU-32 1,000 lb. JDAM (Joint Direct Attack
Munition) PGMs on BRU-46 bomb racks.
e. External carriage of 600 gal fuel tanks, AIM-9 and AIM-120 missiles.
—
I see no reason why this should be secret. Emergency response does need this data. Non-US people who’s job it is to know such data will know it by now anyhow.
Just a second, someone is knocking at my door …
Bah, the post already noted that, somewhere below where my eyes glazed over. if someone could delete my previous post…
Anyhow: As people have mentioned the location of oxygen bottles is no biggie. Terrorists have committed to using MANPADS against aircraft anyways, and more likely than not they probably had aircraft mechanics in their sleeper cells pulling viable intel on aircraft weakpoints before 9/11, rather than just focusing on aircraft pilots to fly things kamikaze into towers.
The terrorists aren’t likely to try and target the plane, not without a better idea on how the Secret Service is going to position itself. If you were in place to put a sniper on AF1, wouldn’t you be better served shooting Bush walking out of the plane anyways?
Enjoyed browsing through the site. Keep up the good work. Greetings
Thank you for your work in 2006 and all the best for 2007.
Fantastic article covering some points I really needed some good usability info for.
Best regards from Poland
Enjoyed browsing through the site. Keep up the good work. Greetings from Poland
LoL! You have fantastic site and very interest articles. Enjoyed browsing through the site. Keep up the good work. Thanks and Greetings
I think these blog is really useful for new comers and Excellent resource list.
Fantastic article covering some points I really needed some good usability info for.
Excellent article it
As people have mentioned the location of oxygen bottles is no biggie
Keep up the good work!
Very good and great site with very good look and perfect information…i like it
I searched a long time for such an great article. Thank you
Great article, can I translate it and put on my site?
Enjoyed browsing through the site.
Excellent article it
Good article and site. Congratulations
Good article and site. Congratulations
Really nice article.Greatings
Excellent article it
Fantastic article covering some points I really needed some good usability info for.
Best regards
Bah, the post already noted that, somewhere below where my eyes glazed over. if someone could delete my previous post…
Hello this is nice site more information in this archives. Thanks!
Good site.Congrats.
This article is very interesting and written by some clever guy.:) Thank you!
Thanks for this article. I like your posts
hey! your article is great. thanks
Hello
Nice one. good explanation of the topic
Greetings
Thanx a lot! This is very useful.
Fantastic article covering some points I really needed some good usability info for.
Nice, Air Force One is the safest airplane in the world… :P thank you very much was quite interesting
Thank you for your work in 2006 and all the best for 2007
“Air Force One Scare; Real Security Sacrificed” – Good work. Cogratulations
I really wish we can have something like this here in our place. I wonder why do people in authority release such a confidential list of information?
Thanks so very much for taking your time to create this very useful and informative site. I have learned a lot from your site. Thanks!!
Thanx for this very useful and informative article
I have read integrity with great amenity
I have read integrity with great amenity
an article in great demand! Many thanks!
Andy
an article in great demand! Many thanks!
Andy
Outgoing links are good for you!
thx for the great stuff. keep up your nice work! 10 points!
great, thank you for sharing this with us.
Thank you, I found it very interesting; especially when there is not many such information on the net
Thanks for very interesting article.
Great article indeed. I like it very much. Well done
Hey! your article is great. Thanks!
Good idea! Best regards
thanks for information
Really an interesting article about the Air Force One
Well done
Hey , thank you very much for this great stuff! Keep up your great work! Greetings Daniel
Thanks for this article. it is very useful for me.
When opening the weapons bay doors, to
prevent injury or death to personnel, insure
that area under weapons bay doors is clear
of personnel and equipment before opening.
Thanks for your article.
Sd cardSd card
Fantastic article covering some points I really needed some good usability info for.
Thanks defensetech.org
Enjoyed browsing through the site. Keep up the good wo
Thanks
Thanks
Good website – thank you
Good job. Thanks
Excellent article it
Thanks for very interesting article. btw. I really enjoyed reading all of your posts. It
Thanks for very interesting article. btw. I really enjoyed reading all of your posts. It
I think these blog is really useful for new comers and Excellent resource list..
I think these blog is really useful for new comers and Excellent resource list..
Great
There are many useful informations in this article. Thanks and greetings from Thuringia!
Fantastic article !
Fantastic article
excellent information
Thanks you all
Gute Internetseite! Tamada
Gute Internetseite! Tamada
thanksss
thansk
Thanks very nice cicicocuk
There are many useful informations in this great article…I really enjoy reading the whole blog that you write. Thanks!
There are many useful informations in this great article
There are many useful informations in this great article…I really enjoy reading the whole blog that you write. Thanks!
There are many useful informations in this great article
There are many useful informations in this great article…I really enjoy reading the whole blog that you write. Thanks!
There are many useful informations in this great article
Thank You for another very interesting article. So please try to keep up the great work all the time.
Thanks for very interesting article.
Fantastic article covering some points I really needed some good usability info for.
Best regards
Bah, the post already noted that, somewhere below where my eyes glazed over. if someone could delete my previous post…
Anyhow: As people have mentioned the location of oxygen bottles is no biggie. Terrorists have committed to using MANPADS against aircraft anyways, and more likely than not they probably had aircraft mechanics in their sleeper cells pulling viable intel on aircraft weakpoints before 9/11, rather than just focusing on aircraft pilots to fly things kamikaze into towers.
The terrorists aren’t likely to try and target the plane, not without a better idea on how the Secret Service is going to position itself. If you were in place to put a sniper on AF1, wouldn’t you be better served shooting Bush walking out of the plane anyways?
thankss too
Three phrases should be among the most common in our daily usage. They are: Thank you, I am grateful and I appreciate.
“We have very clear policies of what should be on the Web,”
Just searched some 3 minutes and found this:
thanks admin Love is
ty admin
Dave, yes, feel free to do the change in the source code.
very nice thank you.
thanks
According to Dell the reason for the delay was the drivers weren’t ready and their app which helps automate the installation process was not ready. Google it and you’ll find the stories
thanks admin
thanks
thank you for article
Thanks – really useful article (again). The one I was actually looking for turned out to be elsewhere – have a look and see what you think.
As people have mentioned the location of oxygen bottles is no biggie
Good idea! Best regards
Good idea! Best regards
Good idea! Best regards
thanks very nice
interesting
thanks admin
nice log..
nice log..
THANKS
thanksssssssssssssssssssssss
great insight post, interesting
Thanks for sharing.
thank you wery mach
Great stuff here man..
I agree 100% with chris!
keep up the good work!
Bah, the post already noted that, somewhere below where my eyes glazed over. if someone could delete my previous post…
Anyhow: As people have mentioned the location of oxygen bottles is no biggie. Terrorists have committed to using MANPADS against aircraft anyways, and more likely than not they probably had aircraft mechanics in their sleeper cells pulling viable intel on aircraft weakpoints before 9/11, rather than just focusing on aircraft pilots to fly things kamikaze into towers.
The terrorists aren’t likely to try and target the plane, not without a better idea on how the Secret Service is going to position itself. If you were in place to put a sniper on AF1, wouldn’t you be better served shooting Bush walking out of the plane anyways?
Thanks for very interesting article. btw. I really enjoyed reading all of your posts. It
VI
?
?
?
?
?
?
?
nice article.
Tolle Deko und Hochzeitskleider. Russische Hochzeitsdekoration, Brautmode und Brautkleider.
Hochzeitshalle Dekoration auf der deutsch-russischen Hochzeit, deutsch-Russische Hochzeit geplant in Deutschland. Hochzeitshalle dekorieren. Hochzeitshalle und russische Dekos: Tischdeko & Kerzen + Girlanden + Lichterketten.
Deko-Teams
Thanks for this article.
Very good article
Thanks for very interesting article.
Thank you for your amazing site.
Brautkleider
Nice post. Well done. Thanks.
Really impressive. Thanks.
Really impressive. Thanks.
thanks you….
very nice blogs.
Good news
Thank you
I hope everybody read this article
very thanks
thanks admin topunuzun amk
thanks admin a.q
very thanks
very thanks
very thanks
very thanks you
This is interesting article, I did not it think that it yes. Interesting it knew persons about this how much. Sorry if I wrote bad there now my English is novice and I do not it write yet good.
Excellent article it
This is interesting article, I did not it think that it yes. Interesting it knew persons about this how much. Sorry if I wrote bad there now my English is novice and I do not it write yet good.
Hello.
I recently saw an article written by a professor, which confirm that what is written here. I agree with that.
:)
from out of town it nice to get the specifics on how to gain acces to the cocpit to get the crew out, safety any weapons and identify any hazards that may not be part of our normal operating procedures. The lost of this web page and the information contained in it will most likly killing first responders because of a mistake preformed on an aircraft they were not prepared for or familar with.
I would think a hosting company would want their customers making money off their websites, so they would continue hosting through them and potentially buy more hosting through them
I would think a hosting company would want their customers making money off their websites, so they would continue hosting through them and potentially buy more hosting through them
Thanks for very interesting article. btw. I really enjoyed reading all of your posts. It
Terrorists have committed to using MANPADS against aircraft anyways, and more likely than not they probably had aircraft mechanics in their sleeper cells pulling viable intel on aircraft weakpoints before 9/11, rather than just focusing on aircraft pilots to fly things kamikaze into towers.
Excellent article it
Very useful advices. I think I will search more about this on the Net, Guys. Many thanks
Hi. You know what guys? I think this is very good idea, but I am affraid but not for me :|
I like to cook very at home. Greetings from Poland.
Game days, he pursued JP, clothes completely F10, fire 8. Hands and feet are completely F10. Knife is the Z10. WGF complete sets of 80. Certainly, he spent a lot of SOF gold. He is also very good friends. They play with friends are also now 10 knives. But one day, the things of him was lost, we are very sad.
maybe I give you too much pressure, let you give up this feeling, I really want to know that do you really can forget me and forget the day s about we together to play and together to upgrade and together to earn the kamas, you really can forget
I spend my pin money to bought the 2moon dil, maybe some people said that I was very foolish, but I did not care about other people
every day I spend many time to play the game, in order to gad a tall level, I bought many cabal gold, finally by my effort I had a tall level.
who know that this play was playing for more than a year, in this year I spend many time to play this game and spend much money to bought the cheap kamas, although in order to her I give up many chance, but in my mind I did not had a little sad or regret, because I know that she was worth me to love.
Thank you for this blog, I try to visit it often because it is a great source of information for me. Keep up with this great work you’ve made already! Greetings!
Now when I talked with them, I often told them how to bought the cheap Final Fantasy XI Gold, they all said that I had a great changed, I am very happy
Thank you for this blog, I try to visit it often because it is a great source of information for me. Keep up with this great work you’ve made already! Greetings!
Hi everyone.
set2 2 [url=2]2[/url]
set2 2 [url=2]2[/url]
set2 2 [url=2]2[/url]
set2 2 [url=2]2[/url]
Great site.
Hi everyone.
set2 2 [url=2]2[/url]
set2 2 [url=2]2[/url]
set2 2 [url=2]2[/url]
set2 2 [url=2]2[/url]
Great site.
thanks,
Diyet Yemek Tarifleri Listeleri
ty defensetech
another example of the personality cult we’ve built around the office of the President. Perhaps if the firefighter arrange for a parade and 21-gun salute they will then be allowed to put out the damned fire.
thanks, very nice
If you are doing your makeup, wedding invitations before your dress is on wedding dresses to touch up the wedding gowns is on, use a towel or bridal gowns to make sure no smudge hits the dress.If you lace front wigs spend time to make your own wedding invitation, lace wigs save a buck and start to design and make your own invitation. You full lace wigs the quality of any of your wedding items.Invitations can be cheap wedding invitations a bride and grooms individual style. Buying bridesmaid dresses takes time, but not nearly as much time as getting wedding invitations. Don’t wait too long to get started finding your invitations. As with dresses and even ivitations, a good starting point is to shop around and see what is offered.
If you are doing your makeup, wedding invitations before your dress is on wedding dresses to touch up the wedding gowns is on, use a towel or bridal gowns to make sure no smudge hits the dress.If you lace front wigs spend time to make your own wedding invitation, lace wigs save a buck and start to design and make your own invitation. You full lace wigs the quality of any of your wedding items.Invitations can be cheap wedding invitations a bride and grooms individual style. Buying bridesmaid dresses takes time, but not nearly as much time as getting wedding invitations. Don’t wait too long to get started finding your invitations. As with dresses and even ivitations, a good starting point is to shop around and see what is offered.
Diyet Yemek Tarifleri Listeleri
thanks admin says
I’m glad to see they took it down finally.
Muhabbet
Thanks Adminn
Thanks admin
thanks for all..
thanks for this post..
BEDAVA OYUN
thx admin..
thx admin..
thank you admin..
for mobil web site
for security password
arkada?l?k sitesi
thank you admin..
kamera ?akalar?, erotik ?akalar
thanks
I like air force one.
I like air force one.
http://fr.ogigames.com
I like air force oneeeee.
http://de.ogigames.com
I like air force oneeeee.
http://ru.ogigames.com
I like air force oneeeee.
http://www.ogigames.com
thanks
i hate air force one